So it seems that Windows 8.1 will enable users to skip ‘Metro’ on startup. While I can believe that the current Metro experience (with no way to skip it on boot) would hurt Windows sales, I’m not sure that allowing users to skip it is really a good thing.

How many users will just skip Metro and never see how awesome it is on their touch based devices? Since pretty much all of us hate change, I have to think that it’s going to be a fairly high number of users.

I think that a smarter strategy would be to boot to a traditional desktop environment on a traditional desktop computer. If you have no touch capabilities, you see the desktop we are all used to. If you have a device with touch, you get Metro.

I liked that Microsoft was all in, taking this half step back will only hurt the Metro UI.

via Bob Martens

3 responses to “Allowing Users to skip ‘Metro’ is a Bad Idea”

  1. Bob Avatar

    I would hope that is what they ultimately do. As a (forced) user of Windows 8 … it is quite terrible on the desktop and laptop, but it works really well where it was designed to work: tablets.

    I would think that keeping Windows 8 RT as Metro-only would be a good way of doing things.

  2. Otto Avatar

    The screenshots I saw of the Metro UI prevented me from purchasing Windows 8 entirely.

    I’ll just wait for the next version of Windows, thanks, after they drop that sort of nonsense. Windows 7 is fine for me for now.

    1. Curtis McHale Avatar
      Curtis McHale

      I do think that there are a host of users (like yourself or maybe me) for whom Metro just won’t work at all right now. But for people like my Mom or brother Metro is great, on a touch based device.

      I’m much more excited about what Microsoft is doing with Windows than what Apple is doing with OSX right now, and I’m an OSX guy full time.

To respond on your own website, enter the URL of your response which should contain a link to this post’s permalink URL. Your response will then appear (possibly after moderation) on this page. Want to update or remove your response? Update or delete your post and re-enter your post’s URL again. (Find out more about Webmentions.)