I wrote long ago about how Captcha’s are terrible for site usability, seems that one company wants to solve it by making them mini games.

I must applaud the effort to change how they work, and make them easier for users to pass while still hard for machines. Captcha’s still suck though. I still stand behind what I said in my earlier post.

We should be using things like honey pot form elements and Akismet to deal with spam. As I said, spam is the web site owner’s problem not the problem of the user. Stop pushing your problem on to someone else.

2 responses to “Captcha’s Still Suck”

  1. Eric Mann Avatar

    Every now and then, I’m faced with a captcha. What’s worse is that, in an effort to make them harder for computers, they’re nearly impossible for humans. I once had to complete a captcha to order something online … and ended up submitting the form a total of 17 times because I kept getting the captcha wrong.

    If someone who works in technology can’t cope with the technical tools that prevent spam, what hope is there for non-tech-savvy users (i.e. my parents)?

    1. curtismchale Avatar
      curtismchale

      There is no hope for them. I end up doing a bunch of them for my wife when she can’t, and she is fairly technically savvy. Like I say, it’s just pushing the solution to the issue of spam on to the people that it doesn’t actually affect and decreases usability. Bad practice.

To respond on your own website, enter the URL of your response which should contain a link to this post’s permalink URL. Your response will then appear (possibly after moderation) on this page. Want to update or remove your response? Update or delete your post and re-enter your post’s URL again. (Find out more about Webmentions.)